Let’s get this out of the way right now: I was always more of a Backstreet Boys girl. My heart was firmly in Camp BSB, doodling “Kieran Carter” in my notebook because Nick Carter was obviously going to randomly sail from Tampa to Lake Superior and fall in love with me. NSYNC? They were just... fine. That said, when NSYNC released Home for Christmas in 1998, even I had to admit they absolutely nailed “Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays.” And yes, it serves as yet another reminder why JC Chasez is the best member of *NSYNC; fight me in the comments.
This song is everything a holiday bop should be: joyful, cheesy in the best way, and guaranteed to get stuck in your head for days. But what makes it so endearing? Let’s break it down like it’s a boy-band dance routine.
A Pop Christmas Anthem for the Ages
If you grew up in the late ’90s, NSYNC’s “Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays” instantly transports you back to a time of glittery crop tops, butterfly hair clips, and boy bands ruling TRL. It’s the kind of track that feels like Christmas morning, complete with the thrill of unwrapping a shiny new Walkman. Add in its infectious chorus—“Merry Christmas! Happy Holidays!”—and you’ve got an earworm you don’t want to escape. It’s the song you catch yourself humming while stress-wrapping gifts at midnight, proof of its enduring charm.
Even its message is ahead of its time. While the song’s title may say “Merry Christmas,” it also includes a cheerful “Happy Holidays,” making it refreshingly inclusive long before that became the norm. NSYNC was out here spreading joy to everyone, no matter what they celebrate. And let’s not forget JC Chasez, whose buttery smooth vocals and heavenly high notes steal the show. Sure, Justin Timberlake was the face of the group, but this track is where JC’s talent truly shines. If you weren’t already a JC fan, this song should convert you.
Then there’s the music video, which is a glorious display of campy holiday fun. The guys are dressed as modern Santas, dancing and spreading joy like holiday superheroes. It’s over-the-top, cheesy in the best way, and exactly the kind of festive spirit we need every December.
On a technical level, the song works because it nails the basics of great holiday music. Written in a major key, it feels naturally happy and festive. The tight harmonies give it a warm, choir-like glow that perfectly complements the season, while the instrumentation—jingle bells, synths, and orchestral hits—screams Christmas in all the best ways. The call-and-response moments in the bridge practically beg you to sing along, adding to its interactive joy. And the best part? It’s simple. No unnecessary key changes or overproduction—just pure, unadulterated holiday cheer.
The Whole Album Deserves Its Flowers
While NSYNC’s Home for Christmas might not be as universally remembered as Mariah Carey’s Merry Christmas, it’s a hidden gem of late ’90s holiday pop. This album is one of the most cohesive festive offerings of the era, blending original songs and timeless classics into a seamless holiday experience. Tracks like “Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays” (an undeniable masterpiece) stand alongside updated takes on staples like “O Holy Night” and “The First Noel.” NSYNC’s version of “O Holy Night” is a pure vocal showcase, flexing their harmonies and reminding everyone that, yes, they could actually sing.
The album feels like a big, cozy Christmas hug. Its slick production combines warm harmonies, pop beats, and just the right amount of holiday sparkle. It’s unmistakably late ’90s in its sound, but it leans fully into the festive vibe, creating a sense of thematic cohesion. Tracks like “The First Noel” and “Silent Night” are a harmonic delight, but JC Chasez (our unsung hero) and Justin Timberlake take the spotlight on many lead vocals, elevating the songs into something special. It was also an opportunity for Chris, Joey, and Lance to shine on lead vocals - something that we hadn't really heard on previous records.
There’s also a playfulness to the album that makes it irresistibly fun. “Under My Tree” may be a touch more suggestive than you’d expect from a family-friendly record, but it’s peak boy-band cheekiness—perfectly suited to the holiday season. Meanwhile, tracks like “I Never Knew the Meaning of Christmas” tap into the romanticized warmth we all associate with the holidays, tugging at your heartstrings in the best way. They were singing to me, damn it!
Why Was NSYNC Doing This in 1998?
At the time, NSYNC was still fighting to make their mark in the U.S. after a successful European debut. Their Christmas album, Home for Christmas, was a savvy move to solidify their presence and showcase their harmonies. And while Backstreet Boys were busy touring and prepping their game-changing Millennium album, NSYNC jumped into the holiday music space that BSB hadn’t touched. Smart, right?
It was a strategic play to differentiate themselves from BSB’s more serious pop domination. And guess what? It worked. Even a Backstreet fangirl like me couldn’t ignore how good this song was.
This is where this frustrated fangirl has to admit that Lou Pearlman—infamous boyband Svengali and documented con artist—who is credited as sole executive producer on the album, was actually really good at putting together boybands and marketing them against each other. Making the play for a Christmas album and the now legendary Disney In Concert broadcast in the same year cemented NSYNC as a long-lasting piece of American history. Yes, that is a bold statement, and I stand by it.
Why NSYNC's Christmas Album Still Matters
“Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays” isn’t just a song; it’s a cultural artifact of the millennial pop era. It’s the song you play while decorating the tree, sipping your Starbucks red cup, and pretending you’re not bitter about JC’s lack of solo career success.
This song reminds us that the holidays are about joy, togetherness, and—let’s be honest—a little bit of camp. Whether you’re an *NSYNC fan, a die-hard Backstreet stan, or someone who loves a good Christmas bop, this track has earned its place on every holiday playlist.
So, here’s to *NSYNC for giving us a song that slaps, sparkles, and spreads holiday cheer. And here’s to JC Chasez, the true MVP of this timeless classic.
Stay tuned for the next installment in this millennial pop Christmas album series, where I’ll tackle Hanson’s two Christmas albums. Yes, they made two. And yes, it’s just as “MMMBop” as you imagine. 🎄
Comments